Saturday Morning Reads: Do Marketers Need to Become Social Psychologists?

As marketers, how much psychology do we need to understand to make sense of what our customers are doing socially?

Are they trying to tell us what they want or need by engaging? Or, is it simply that they are utilizing social networking to become influential among their peers?

What happens when a customer becomes popular within his or her chosen social network? What are the chances that a brand can piggyback on this newfound influence (i.e. brand evangelism or word of mouth)? On the other hand, could popularity and potential narcissism cause a customer to leap to a more desirable brand that is as equally popular as them?

We know that people join social networks because they want to be part of a group. Should marketers be required to have a deep understanding of group dynamics in order to analyze group interactions and how they may or may not impact business efforts?

Will the more socially advanced organizations expect that their marketers will understand how social networks and psychology affect market dynamics in order to project future revenues?

Psychology Today: The Psychology of Social Networking

“One intuitive hypothesis is that “popular” people (those with vast, far-reaching, and significant networks or contacts) will have connections both in the real as well as in the virtual world; thus the number of people one deals with in the real or physical world should be positively correlated with the number of virtual or electronic contacts one has.”

Alexandra Samuel: Group identity and the psychology of social media

“One of the primary themes of my dissertation was the power of group identity as a motivation for participation. Reading the social psychological literature on group identity, it became clear that people join groups that reinforce positive ascriptive identity — those identities that are positively valued in our society. The practical implication is that you need to organize your community’s membership around identities people feel good about: I’m far more likely to identify myself as a member of ‘parents of gifted children’ than I am to join up with ‘compulsive nail-biters’.”

The Layman’s Guide to Psychology: The Psychology of Twitter, Facebook, and Other Social Networking Devices

“Narcissism is generally not a celebrated trait. Why then is social networking so widely accepted if it is so related to narcissistic tendencies? Is it possible that the internet merely allows an all-to-easy outlet for these tendencies to surface from people who may otherwise not possess them? According to one study, this seems to be the case.

Some people are far more shy than others but to a certain extent we all possess a little of this–even the “kings of narcissism”. Being shy is a defensive measure that allows an individual to protect themselves from ridicule, or worse. The internet has allowed individuals an uncanny intimacy while maintaining a near-infinite level of physical separation.”

CompuKol Connection: The Psychology Behind Social Media

If you approach your social media marketing campaign from a psychological angle, you will see that people respond to your business offerings and to you as an individual. You will see that they will gladly spread the word about your products and services as well as your expertise in your niche. People will be speaking about you and on your behalf before you know it and that, of course, brings you another step closer to great success.”

MIT Press Journals: Simulating Market Dynamics: Interactions between Consumer Psychology and Social Networks

“Watts and Strogatz [18] proposed a model for social networks that describes the small-world and clustering characteristics in networks. This model includes empirically found characteristics of social networks, namely the small-world effect [11] and the clustering effect [12]. The small-world effect refers to the experience that despite the large population, the map of who knows whom is such that we are all very closely connected to one another. The clustering characteristic refers to the existence of clusters in social networks. People’s circles of acquaintance tend to overlap to a great extent. Your friend’s friends are likely also to be your friends.

Amaral et al. [1] showed that the scale-free network hypothesis is more complex. They analyzed different types of networks and found also networks that followed the power law up to a sharp cutoff. For example, a highly connected node may refuse to accept new connections because of capacity and cost constraints, or a well-connected node may die. Amaral et al. [1] proposed an adjustment of the Barabasi-Albert model by including the option that a node in the network becomes inactive with a certain probability. Since new nodes can only connect with active nodes, they are able to reproduce different classes of observed networks. This approach may be more correct in modeling consumer networks, as consumers functioning as a hub in a network will be limited in the number of contacts they have.

The results presented in this article indicate that besides psychological needs and decision processes, also the size and shape of the network involved in consumer decision making have an important influence on how the market organizes itself. Especially when the satisfaction per unit of consumption is high, as is often the case with products that satisfy lower needs, the results suggest that the shape of the network has serious consequences for the number of products that dominate the market. The results show that a scale-free network yields a market dominated by far fewer products than in the small-world network with a limited number of random links. Even for low visibility products the hubs have a strong influence on which products other agents consume.”

Happy reading!

[Image Source: thisismarilyn.com]

Even More Goodness! Related Posts:

6 Responses to “Saturday Morning Reads: Do Marketers Need to Become Social Psychologists?”

  • Truly challenging questions and powerful links Beth. I’ve always believed that true marketing requires a deep understanding of what lies beneath people’s actions and reactions, and psychology delves into both to help us achieve that goal. Thank you for sharing! See you soon. ~Paul

  • As a marketer, I’ve always been interested in aspects of psychology, especially buying behavior and the formation of attitudes. Social media gives me a chance to connect with people I wouldn’t normally get to meet. I’m naturally outgoing, so FB and Twitter feel comfortable. A lot of people use SM simply to ply their wares, and I unfollow them. I assume the rest enjoy the sharing of ideas that SM allows. I’d like to think we aren’t all that narcissistic! We’re just friendly!

  • The more we understand how and why a customer behaves, the better we can work with and market to them in a way that works for them. I have been reading Predictably Irrational by Dan Ariely. Great read the irrational yet predictable behavior on how people make decisions.

  • Thought provoking post! …Thank you!

    As marketers we have internal and external customers with unique buyer persona’s. What the VP of sales versus the VP of marketing want can be dramatically different. However we all serve one customer the CEO and they typically want one common thing: sales to become less of an art and more of a predictable science.

    Marketing has the unique ability and opportunity to solve this unresolved problem and your content touches on this ; Sales is a science when you have good marketing and and art when your marketing sucks! http://www.nosmokeandmirrors.com/2010/04/09/sales-is-a-science-when-you-have-strong-marketing%e2%80%a6-an-art-when-your-marketing-sucks/

    So we need to get in our buyers heads, know their buying process, criteria and behaviors. Once we capture this, our work becomes very powerful and recognized as it results in explosive sales and profit growth.

    Mark Allen Roberts

  • Beth Harte:

    Paul, I couldn’t agree more. But I wonder how many marketers are ready to take on that challenge. And, you’re welcome…glad you liked the post!

    John, understanding buying behavior—specifically motivation & attitudes—will make any marketer the “Golden Child” in an organization, it’s so very important. From a social media perspective, I think you are talking about personal use while I was focused solely on business. What interests me about what you said is that you unfollow people who ‘ply their wares.’ As a marketer, do you think customers feel this way about businesses who try to connect socially?

    LJ, indeed. However, I’d like to think we aren’t marketing “to them” as much as we are offering products/services we know they want or need and communicating in a manner that’s acceptable. A two-way street, per se. Dan Ariely’s book is a great one for marketers to read. Have you read “The Upside of Irrationality” yet?

    Mark (or is it Mark Allen?), you’re welcome! Very true marketers have two masters, always. I think we are far from marketing and sales (as a function of marketing) being totally predicable, but integrated marketing does help from that perspective. The first step is to understand it’s okay to build relationships with customers. The second step is to understand that marketing doesn’t equal promotions/communications only. That’s 1/3 of the equation. When you have the entire equation from a customer’s perspective, that’s when you have art and a science—a might combination, indeed! ;-)

    Some other books you might find interesting:

    Neuromarketing: Understanding the Buy Buttons in Your Customer’s Brain by Patrick Renvoise and Christophe Morin

    The Buying Brain: Secrets for Selling to the Subconscious Mind by A. K. Pradeep

    Buyology: Truth and Lies About Why We Buy by Martin Lindstrom and Paco Underhill

    The Branded Mind: What Neuroscience Really Tells Us about the Puzzle of the Brain and the Brand by Erik Du Plessis

    Gimme! The Human Nature of Successful Marketing by John Hallward

  • [...] Do Marketers Need to Become Social Psychologists? [...]

Creative Commons

Creative Commons License
The Harte of Marketing by Beth Harte is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at www.theharteofmarketing.com. [If you have a question about what you can use from this blog, click on the above Creative Commons link to learn more.]

Co-Author, AoC 3
Why Planning is Important
Interview
I Also Blog At:
Connect With Me
Badges of Honor: